I am currently in a philosophy of religion class and my teacher is an atheist. He
claims that under an Islamic state if a born Muslim converts to another religion he
is killed. Please tell me if this is true.
The punishment for apostasy (riddah) is well-known in Islaamic Sharee’ah. The one who leaves
Islaam will be asked to repent by the Sharee’ah judge in an Islaamic country; if he does not
repent and come back to the true religion, he will be killed as a kaafir and apostate, because of
the command of the Prophet
(peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him): "Whoever
changes his religion, kill him." (Reported by al-Bukhaari, 3017).
It is well-known in Sharee’ah that the punishments (hudood) are not carried out on minors,
because they have not yet reached the age of responsibility; but in the case of those who have
reached the age of responsibility, the punishment (hadd) applies, without a doubt.
The person who knows the truth and believes in it, then turns his back on it, does not deserve
to live. The punishment for apostasy is prescribed for the protection of the religion and as a
deterrent to anyone who is thinking of leaving Islaam. There is no doubt that such a serious
crime must be met with an equally weighty punishment. If the kuffaar do not give people the
freedom to cross a red light, how can we give freedom to people to leave Islaam and disbelieve
in Allaah when they want to?
It seems that the intention of the teacher mentioned in the question was to shock the students
with news of this ruling, in order to mislead them from the way of Allaah. You must respond
and explain to him and the other students as much as you can.
May Allaah make you and us bearers of His Message and defenders of His Sharee’ah.