Thursday 6 Jumada al-ula 1446 - 7 November 2024
English

Her mother died and she misses her very much, so she writes to her and tells her about news of the family

171597

Publication : 20-09-2022

Views : 8270

Question

My mother died – may Allah have mercy on her – approximately three months ago, and I feel that I miss her very much.  Sometimes I feel that I want to talk to her and tell her about our news, and that we miss her very much, so I write a letter on my personal email, in which I write about what I wish I could say to her, then I send the email to myself, and at the end of it I write “May Allah take care of you, my mother.” After that, I feel some kind of relief. Is this permissible or not? Please note that I completely avoid any words of kufr (disbelief) or asking her to pray for me or to intercede for me with Allah. I would never do that, Allah forbid; praise be to Allah, the Lord of the Worlds. It is nothing more than very ordinary words and offering supplication for her, and nothing else.

Answer

Praise be to Allah.

We ask Allah, may He be exalted, to have mercy on your mother and to cause her to dwell in the highest part of al-Firdaws; we ask Him to enable you to bear your loss with patience and to make you steadfast in obedience to Him.

With regard to what you are doing, we think that you should refrain from that, for several reasons:

1.. Writing these messages and words renews your grief, and the scholars disallowed anything that may renew the Muslim’s grief, lest he gave up striving and be afflicted with despair and impatience. For this reason there is a difference of opinion regarding the ruling on women visiting graves, which is either prohibited in all cases, or it is prohibited for women to visit graves frequently. It was said that the reason for that is what could result from that of infractions of Islamic teachings due to the renewal of grief.

Ibn Qudaamah (may Allah have mercy on him) said:

Because women tend to lack patience and become distressed easily, and visiting graves will stir up their grief and renew the memories of the calamity that befell them, and there is no guarantee that this will not lead to women doing things that are not permissible, in contrast to men." (Al-Mughni  2/430).

2.. Writing these messages and letters is distracting you from that which is better for your mother, which is offering supplication for her, asking Allah to grant her mercy and forgiveness. If you stop writing these letters and messages, and you accept the reality of your mother’s death, and you strive hard in offering supplication for her when prostrating, and at the end of the night, that will be better for her than what you are doing.

Hence what we advise you to do is to stop doing this, and to offer a great deal of supplication for her. We ask Allah, may He be exalted, to have mercy on her and to forgive her.

And Allah knows best.

Was this answer helpful?

Source: Islam Q&A